Future of Cloverdale grandstand

These days the Cloverdale grandstand in the fairgrounds is a far cry from the grandstand that I knew as a kid. Today it is the home of Fraser Downs Racetrack and Casino. The casino came into being in late 2003 after the racetrack and many of the backstretch workers petitioned city hall to allow slot machines to help revive the sagging racing industry. Over the next two years the grandstand was revamped into the casino that stands on the fairgrounds today.

But how much life is left in it?

Although the casino has helped the racing keep its head above water, the reality is that wagering is down 10% from the past year and customers have found other venues for sporting entertainment. Purses are dropping, there are fewer race nights, and horse owners are earning less. Many are getting out of the business or relocating to other racetracks where they have a better chance of earning a living.

I've heard that Fraser Downs wants to open a show theatre on the grounds, similar to the Red Robinson theatre in Coquitlam or the River Rock in Richmond. The entertainers that frequent these theatres usually do both of them over a few day period, such as Kenny Rogers, The Beach Boys, and Air Supply. They would need to build the theatre on part of the racetrack ground. Probably be a bigger money earner that the end result between the wagers currently placed and the purse money paid out to the racehorse owners.

There are also grumblings from the provincial government in charge of gaming in BC about combining Thoroughbred and Standardbred racing onto the same racetrack because both breeds run about 6 months of the year, during the opposite months. Thoroughbreds race April to October, while Standardbreds race October to April. Sometimes with a few cross over weekends. The government said this will likely occur within the next 2 years. Between the racetracks in Cloverdale and Vancouver, the government prefers Vancouver - Hastings Park located on the PNE grounds.

More surprisingly the government says if all the horse racing is moved to Hastings Park, then the slot machines at Cloverdale will be relocated to the Great Canadian Casino's other location in Surrey.

So that leaves Fraser Downs Racetrack and Casino without horse racing and without slot machines. What else is left there? No one's going to convince me they'll still build a show theatre without an attached casino to draw patrons in.

Were all the upgrades to the original grandstand worth it for what could very well be less than ten years of actual use? I haven't heard any news on what the fate of the old grandstand will be if the Standardbreds move to Hastings and the slots are moved to the other casino.

Fraser Downs moves into the 2000's.

On New Year's Eve 1999 there was a bring in the millenium event at the Cloverdale Fairgrounds. It was marketed as an event for the whole family. Various tents and exhibits were set up around the fairgrounds and there was horse racing on the track that was advertised as the last horse races anywhere in the world for the century. Admission was $5 or maybe $10, I don't really recall. We bought tickets and it was good for in and out privleges. We only lived a couple of blocks from the fairgrounds so we went home to have something to eat and came back again. Attendance was projected to be 50,000 but only 5,000 tickets were sold.

Kind of the same thing that was happening at the Fraser Downs racetrack. Attendance was down which meant less patrons purchasing wager tickets which ultimately meant less purse money available to the horse owners and trainers. Many of them headed to other tracks in Canada. The problem with that is the tracks in Ontario have a lot of competition. Good horses, good trainers, and good drivers are already established there and its hard for a newcomer to compete, no matter how successful they were in Cloverdale. Many stables headed into Alberta during the summer months where there was a chance to make money but most of them returned to Cloverdale. The winning purse money might be low but a stable with decent horses could earn pretty good money here.

The grumblings continued about wanting to put slot machines into the grandstand and turn it into a casino. Of course everyone connected to the racetrack wanted the slot machines, but there was continued resistance from some City of Surrey elected officials and some locals.

In late 2003 the City of Surrey mayor and council held a meeting at city hall to vote on putting in slot machines at the racetrack in Cloverdale. We went down to city hall to observe and the place was a circus, standing room only. There was a sign up sheet in the lobby for anyone who wanted to address council and members of the audience in the public and a lot of people had signed up to speak.

A former politician had given a copy of his speech to my father so I'd had a peek at it beforehand, but he didn't read it, doing the old politician trick of having someone else read it and have them look like an idiot. A neighbor of ours in Dogwood Gardens read it and it was hilarious. He really made a fool out of himself. Another man in the crowd stood up to say his objection was the casino would bring in more patrons and they would all be litterbugs and throw garbage all over and the children walking to school would trip over it. That brought a lot of laughs. Didn't their parents ever teach them they should watch where they're walking? To make a long story short and what we all know today, council approved the slot machines and casino and the racetrack managed to get some temporary slots installed almost immediately.

The grandstand underwent another renovation as Fraser Downs underwent the task of turning the old building into a casino that would attract a new clientele. For the most part they succeeded. The new grandstand is much more appealing than the one that existed in the 80's. The only thing I fault it with is that there is really no place for patrons who want to sit down and watch the horse races. Now one can argue that there are all kinds of places where people can watch the racing such as the Clubhouse or Homestretch restaurants, both of which you have to shell out some money if you want to sit in these sections and watch the racing. The only place to watch the horse racing for free are outside at track level either in front of the grandstand or alongside the parking lot fences, and this might not be desirable depending on the weather. Or there is a pub style restaurant on the ground floor near the racetrack's finish line. There are a couple of betting windows here. We tried to come one night and have a meal here but most of the tables were full of people. It was unknown whether patrons sit down at a table and wait for one of the few servers to come over and take an order or to go up to the counter and place an order and no one would stop and answer us, so we ended up leaving and going out for sushi.

The Fraser Downs casino does seem to be successful, judging by the full parking lots on weekends and lots of cars in the lot the rest of the week. But has the extra income from the casino really helped the horse race purses and winnings the owners can expect? Shortly after the casino opened it appeared the purses did increase but since then it appears that while some class of races have increased, most have stayed the same. The scuttlebuck from casino employees is that the slots revenue is carrying the racing and that wagering has not significantly increased with the inception of the casino. Although the casino is doing the well, the clientele do not appear to be overly interested in horse racing.

Interesting times as Fraser Downs enters a new decade.

Cloverdale Raceway becomes Fraser Downs

I decided its about time to continue where I left off on the Cloverdale Raceway and the grandstand in the 80's.

As Cloverdale Raceway entered the 1990's, attendance was diminishing and racing was down to 3 times a week - Friday night, Saturday, and Sunday - between October and April. On statutory holidays there would be afternoon racing if the holiday fell on a week day. There were also a couple of extra nights racing starting in September and occasionally into late April or early May. During the summer months the Standardbred horses raced at Sandown Raceway, near the ferry terminal at Sidney on Vancouver Island, about a half hour drive from Victoria.

Patrons were no longer flocking to Cloverdale on racenights they way they had been in the early 80's. People were finding other forms of entertainment with slot machines and tables opening around the Lower Mainland. Cloverdale Raceway stopped charging for parking in the fairgrounds parking lot and stopped charging admission into the grandstand in an effort to boost attendance by making it more consumer friendly and accessible. The grandstand underwent more renovations and The Clubhouse became a well known dining experience, whether or not a patron was interested in horse racing, with an outstanding buffet.

In 1996 the name changed from Cloverdale Raceway to Fraser Downs. Racing nights had their ups and downs, anywhere from two nights to four nights a week. The racetrack had trouble keeping quality horses, trainers, and drivers due to low purses. Anyone with talent and a good stable of horses headed to other Canadian racetracks with higher purses where they had a better chance of earning a decent living.

Throughout the late nineties the racetrack management attempted to get interest to install slot machines in the grandstand, believing this would be the only solution to saving the racetrack, but mostly their efforts fell on deaf ears. Horse owners and their stables headed east, purses remained low in Cloverdale, and the remaining horse people stuck it out hoping things would get better.

More about Cloverdale fairground's racetrack

When the grandstand at the Cloverdale fairgrounds transitioned into spectator seating for the Standardbred horse racing, changes came slowly. Most notably enclosing the structure, gating it in, so as to control paid admission into the grandstand. $2/person if memory serves correctly and back then racing was 5 times a week from mid-October to mid-April, during the off season for the Thoroughbred racing at Hastings Park in Vancouver.

By the mid-80's attendance was slacking off a bit. Other forms of entertainment were pulling racing aficionados away from the Cloverdale Raceway. I remember when traffic on racing nights was lined up down 176th Street to the Fraser Highway and sometimes even further north of the Fraser Highway. Bumper to bumper crawl into Cloverdale, trying to turn left onto 60th Avenue and the entrances to the fairgrounds. Back then there was no priority left hand turn lane signal.

Then in the mid-80's racing downsized to 4 times a week. I don't recall for sure, but I think it was Monday night racing that was bumped, leaving racing on Wednesday and Friday nights, and during the afternoons on Saturday and Sunday. Then the change was made from Wednesday night to Thursday night so that meant Standardbred racing was on 4 consecutive days.

Food service in the grandstand on racing nights consisted of a couple of hot dog and hamburger stands. There were a lot of wagering windows open where tellers took racer's bets.

There were a lot of horses still racing in Cloverdale even though the purses weren't all that great. There were several large horse barns in the backstretch area plus a couple of smaller horse barns closer to the grandstand on the parking lot side.

That left 6 months of the year when there was no racing at Cloverdale. During the off season Standardbreds shipping over to Sandown Park on Vancouver Island or over to one of the tracks in Alberta. There was also a couple of weekends of racing in mid-September, the fair meet, which was in conjunction with the now defunct fall fair that used to be held at the Cloverdale fairgrounds.

The Cloverdale racetrack headed into the 90's with a waning popularity.

More on the Cloverdale fairgrounds grandstand

With a couple of recent posts about the grandstand at the Cloverdale fairgrounds and how we enjoyed playing there as kids, I got to thinking about when that grandstand became fully enclosed.

When I was growing up, the grandstand was covered with a roof on top, but overwise open to the elements. After the Standardbred horse racing started in the mid-70's, the grandstand remained open for a few years, but eventually was partly enclosed, leaving part of the grandstand open to the elements and where the smokers had to sit.

But when was it entirely enclosed? I really don't know for sure, but my guess is around 20 years ago. So say somewhere in the late 80's to early 90's.

I started thinking about that because of the recent updates on the news about the Olympic torch making its way around British Columbia. Back in early 1988 or maybe it was late 1987, another Olympic torch was making its way around BC on its way to the winter Olympics in Calgary. My mother was quite excited about it and was planning to go to the fairgrounds for a torch event while it passed through town. It didn't interest me, but I happened to be shopping at Willowbrook Mall a day or two beforehand, and some volunteers were selling candles with a handle to make it look like a torch, proceeds going to some Olympic event. The idea was that you'd be able to light your candle with the flame from the Olympic torch. They were $2 apiece so I bought one and gave it to Mother to take to the Cloverdale fairgrounds for the festivities.

So this is the only evidence I have that the grandstand was still not fully enclosed because Mother was outside while the Olympic torch came into the track area in front of the grandstand. Many in the crowd had the same candles that I'd bought for Mother and some were able to be lit from the torch. From there everyone in the grandstand passed the flame along from candle to candle until they were all lit. There's no way that would have happened if they'd been inside the enclosed section of the grandstand.

As for a repeat performance at the Cloverdale fairgrounds this year, I don't see it listed on the Olympic torch's route. The torch will be going through Cloverdale on Monday February 8, running along Highway 10 at approximately 2:30 in the afternoon and is supposed to stop briefly at the Surrey Museum.

The grandstand at the Cloverdale fairgrounds

When I was growing up in Cloverdale the grandstand was a lot different than the one that is standing there today. The grandstand back then were rows of bleachers, undercover with a roof overhead, but still open to the elements. In other words if it was raining, one could stay reasonably dry in the bleachers depending on where you were sitting, but if it was cold and windy, everyone was subject to that. This was where people sat and watched the rodeo and other events that might be happening in the infield throughout the year.

At the top of the grandstand, the nosebleed section, the building had window openings. No glass in them. People standing at the top could hang outside and wave to people below in the parking lot or out on 60th Avenue.

There were washrooms on the parking lot level that were open year round. Unlocked. Very convenient when we were playing over at Greenaway Park and someone needed to use the toilet, everyone would walk over to the grandstand. And then we'd continue playing in the grandstand, running up and down the steps, and along the benches.

I guess if there were any homeless people in Cloverdale back then this would have been an ideal place for them to stay. A covered place to sleep and washrooms.

By the time Standardbred horse racing came to Cloverdale in the mid 70's, the grandstand underwent a renovation. Seeing as how back then the racetrack charged patrons $2 admission to come in and watch the horse races, it wouldn't do to have open gates with access to the grandstand. Half of the grandstand was completely enclosed so patrons could sit and watch horse races in the winter months in warmth. Though I'm not exactly sure when that half was enclosed, whether or not that was the year horse racing started or a year or two later. The other half of the grandstand was left as it was - covered roof but otherwise open to the weather. Better known as the smoking section. The curling rink was attached to the original grandstand. A new building was built closer to 176th Street in its current location, to make way for the renovations for the racetrack.

By that time I was too old to be playing in the grandstand, running up and down the bleacher stairs and jumping from bench to bench, and then hanging out the window at the top watching the traffic go by on 60th. So I guess the renovation process kind of passed me by. The last generation of Cloverdale kids who got to enjoy playing in the grandstand before the renovations and locking it off to the public.